Season Records (since 1990)
| Year | Wins | Losses | |
| 1990 | 15 | 8 | Regional Champions, State Runner up |
| 1991 | 13 | 10 | Regional Champions, Final Four |
| 1992 | 20 | 8 | Regional Champions, Final Four |
| 1993 | 15 | 6 | Co District Champions |
| 1994 | 15 | 12 | Bi District Champions |
| 1995 | 10 | 12 |
Playoffs |
| 1996 | 17 | 15 |
Playoffs |
| 1997 | |||
| 1998 | |||
| 1999 | |||
| 2000 | 17 | 15 | Regional Champions, Final Four |
| 2001 | 14 | 13 | |
| 2002 | 25 | 9 | District Champions, Regional Champions, State Champions |
| 2003 | 24 | 8 | District Champions |
| 2004 | 25 | 12 | District Champions, Regional Champions, Final Four |
| 2005 | 14 | 14 | Playoffs |
| 2006 | 6 | 20 | Playoffs |
| 2007 | 18 | 13 | Bi District Champions, Regional Champions, FInal Four |
Hitting (min. of 40 at bats)
| At Bats | Hits | Batting Average | |||
| Jeremy Hebert - '94 | 118 | Jeremy Hebert - '96 | 55 | Jeremy Hebert - '94 | .538 |
| Cullen Schaar - '02 | 116 | Russell Lewis - '96 | 50 | Mike Ragan - '88 | .530 |
| Ben Baker - '04 | 114 | Evan Gattis - '04 | 45 | Clayton Nester -'84 | .520 |
| Chris Schaar - '04 | 112 | Kelly Minissale - '03 | 44 | Russell Lewis - '96 | .481 |
| Evan Gattis - '04 | 111 | Clayton Nester - '84 | 44 | Russell Lewis - '95 | .476 |
| Ryan Hood - '04 | 110 | Ben Baker - '04 | 43 | Tony Palomo -'93 | .475 |
| Russell Lewis - '96 | 104 | Jeremy Hebert - '94 | 42 | Paul Brand - '91 | .467 |
| Eric Smith - '96 | 103 | Ben Baker - '05 | 42 | Jeremy Hebert - '96 | .466 |
| John Gebhard - '07 | 95 | Cullen Schaar - '02 | 41 | Evan Gattis - '03 | .465 |
| Paul Brand - '92 | 87 | Eric Smith - '96 | 40 | K.B. Belter -'90 | .444 |
| Doubles | Triples | Homeruns | |||
| Jeremy Hebert - '96 | 19 | Russell Lewis - '96 | 6 | Russell Lewis -'96 | 8 |
| Evan Gattis - '04 | 17 | Kelly Minissale - '03 | 5 | Mike Ragan - '88 | 7 |
| Eric Smith - '96 | 15 | Paul Brand - '92 | 4 | Chris Schaar - '05 | 6 |
| Jeremy Hebert - '94 | 14 | Jeremy Hebert - '94 | 4 | Chris Schaar - 06' | 5 |
| Ben Baker - '05 | 13 | Spencer Jones - '94 | 4 | Evan Gattis - '04 | 5 |
| Dan O'Connell - '92 | 13 | Russell Lewis - '94 | 4 | Evan Gattis - '03 | 5 |
| Ben Baker - '04 | 12 | Mike Ragan - '88 | 4 | Jeremy Hebert - '96 | 5 |
| Russell Lewis - '96 | 11 | John Michael Twichell -'07 | 4 | K.B. Belter - '90 | 5 |
| Evan Gattis - '03 | 11 | Chris Mangelsdorf - '92 | 3 | Clayton Nester - '84 | 5 |
| Chris Schaar - '05 | 10 | Carey Campbell - '92 | 3 | John Michael Twichell -'07 | 5 |
| Runs | RBIs | Stolen Bases | |||
| Jeremy Hebert - '96 | 53 | Russell Lewis - '96 | 53 | Mike Reagan - '88 | 50 |
| Russell Lewis - '96 | 52 | Paul Brand - '92 | 36 | Spencer Jones -'94 | 38 |
| Cullen Schaar - '02 | 40 | Evan Gattis - '04 | 36 | Kelly Minissale - '03 | 29 |
| Chris Schaar - '04 | 38 | Eric Smith - '96 | 33 | Richie Hanley - '90 | 28 |
| Ben Baker - '04 | 37 | Ben Baker - '05 | 32 | Cullen Schaar - '02 | 26 |
| Mike Ragan - '88 | 36 | Jeremy Hebert - '96 | 31 | Mike Ragan - '87 | 25 |
| Carey Campbell - '92 | 34 | Mike Joyce - '02 | 31 | Spencer Jones - '95 | 24 |
| Spencer Jones - '94 | 34 | Brian Sullivan - '02 | 30 | Todd Lane - '91 | 21 |
| Kelly Minissale - '03 | 34 | Ryan Hood - '04 | 29 | Steve Gilmore - '90 | 20 |
| Jason Nester - '92 | 32 | Adam Anderly -'96 Dave Stanford ' 92 | 29 | Mike Ragan - '86 | 19 |
| Walks | On Base % | Slugging % | |||
| Spencer Jones - '96 | 29 | Jason Nester - '92 | .804 | Russell Lewis - '96 | .933 |
| Mike Joyce - '02 | 28 | Mike Ragan - '88 | .753 | Jeremy Hebert - '94 | .859 |
| Mike Ragan - '88 | 28 | Dan O'Connell - '92 | .671 | Jeremy Hebert - '96 | .788 |
| John Michael Twichell-'07 | 27 | Jeremy Hebert - '94 | .656 | Russell Lewis - '95 | .778 |
| Jason Nester - '92 | 25 | Mike Ragan - '87 | .644 | Evan Gattis - '03 | .767 |
| Spencer Jones - '95 | 24 | Carey Campbell - '92 | .625 | Evan Gattis - '04 | .712 |
| Cullen Schaar - '03 | 24 | Evan Gattis - '03 | .617 | Ben Baker - '05 | .695 |
| Jake Hebert - '00 | 23 | Russell Lewis - '96 | .614 | John Michael Twichell - '07 | .685 |
| Mike Ragan - '87 | 22 | Russell Lewis -'95 | .587 | Carey Campbell - '92 | .650 |
| Joe Snapka - '00 Travis Upham -'07 | 22 | Jay Herbst - '00 | .577 | Kelly Minissale - '03 | .648 |
Pitching (min. of 20 innings pitched)
| Innings Pitched | ERA | Strikeouts | |||
| Paul Brand - '92 | 83 | Chris Snapka - '04 | 0.81 | Paul Brand - '92 | 112 |
| Matt Mendenhall - '07 | 68.1 | Eric Smith - '96 | 1.15 | Nick Halovanic - '04 | 88 |
| Nick Halovanic - '02 | 68 | Paul Brand - '92 | 1.35 | Jeremy Hebert -'94 | 75 |
| Graham Wheeler - '00 | 65 | Nick Halovanic - '02 | 1.54 | Graham Wheeler -'00 | 74 |
| Nick Halovanic - '04 | 64.1 | Kelly Minissale - '03 | 1.55 | ||
| Blake Fulton - '93 | 63 | Graham Martin - '03 | 1.71 | Blake Fulton -'93 | 71 |
| Jason Zaragoza - '96 | 58.1 | Michael Gebhard - '02 | 1.77 | Jordan Knight - '05 | 71 |
| Jordan Knight - '05 | 57.2 | Jason Nester - '90 | 1.78 | Nick Halovanic - '02 | 65 |
| Travis Nolen -'95 | 56.2 | Jason Nester - '91 | 2.29 | Jason Nester - '92 | 63 |
| Blake Fulton - '94 | 56.1 | Jeremy Hebert - '94 | 2.30 | Paul Brand - '91 | 61 |
| Wins | Saves | ||
| Nick Halovanic - '02 | 12 | Jordan Hebert - '07 | 4 |
| Paul Brand -'92 | 9 | Paul Brand - '91 | 3 |
| Jason Zaragoza -'96 | 9 | Chris Snapka - '04 | 3 |
| Graham Wheeler - '00 | 9 | Michael Gebhard - '02 | 3 |
| Kelly Minissale - '03 | 8 | Chris Snapka - '05 | 3 |
| Blake Fulton -'93 | 7 | Jason Nester - '91 | 2 |
| Nick Halovanic - '04 | 7 | Paul Brand - '92 | 2 |
| Jordan Knight - '04 | 7 | Jeremy Hebert -'95 | 2 |
| Jason Nester - '91 '92 | 6 | Eric Smith -'96 | 2 |
| Blake Fulton - '94, Jordan Hebert - 07, Matt Mendenhall - 07 | 6 | Michael Gebhard - '03 | 2 |